Most Popular
-
1
Opposition-led Assembly unilaterally passes bill to probe Marine's death
-
2
Inflation eases in April, continues bumpy ride
-
3
Golden chance to liquidate babies’ gold rings?
-
4
Seoul to more than double military drones by 2026 to counter NK threats
-
5
Russia sent more than 165,000 barrels of refined petroleum to N. Korea in March: White House
-
6
Seoul alerts overseas missions to NK terror threats
-
7
Over 60% of S. Koreans support W100m childbirth incentive: survey
-
8
‘Inside Out 2’ adds four new emotions, explores teenage life
-
9
Questions raised over fair promotion of RM, NewJeans
-
10
Key suspects grilled over alleged abuse of power in Marine death inquiry
A lower court on Thursday upheld the military’s ban on “seditious” books including bestseller “Bad Samaritans” which criticizes free market economics.
In 2008 the Defense Ministry blacklisted 23 books which it deemed could negatively affect soldiers’ morale. Publishers and writers responded by filing a suit demanding 190 million won ($160,000) in damages.
The Seoul Central District Court on Thursday ruled the decision lawful and recognized the administration’s autonomy to prohibit some books to protect soldiers’ morale.
“Under the military code of conduct, service members are banned from reading and possessing books, pictures and other forms of printed materials if the content is considered seditious by the defense minister,” Judge Lee Woo-jae said.
He dismissed the plaintiffs’ claim that the prohibition was an infringement of freedom of the press and basic rights.
The complainants included the publisher of Cambridge University economics professor Chang Ha-joon’s “Bad Samaritans,” which was published in 2007 and has sold more than 550,000 copies so far. The ministry criticized it as “anti-capitalist.”
He noted that the measure was taken for soldiers, a very specific group of people, rather than the general public.
“The administration has the autonomy to protect the morale of service members with its own guidelines,” he said adding that the ban does not infringe on their rights.
In 2010, the Constitutional Court ruled the military authorities’ prohibition constitutional.
By Bae Ji-sook (baejisook@heraldcorp.com)
In 2008 the Defense Ministry blacklisted 23 books which it deemed could negatively affect soldiers’ morale. Publishers and writers responded by filing a suit demanding 190 million won ($160,000) in damages.
The Seoul Central District Court on Thursday ruled the decision lawful and recognized the administration’s autonomy to prohibit some books to protect soldiers’ morale.
“Under the military code of conduct, service members are banned from reading and possessing books, pictures and other forms of printed materials if the content is considered seditious by the defense minister,” Judge Lee Woo-jae said.
He dismissed the plaintiffs’ claim that the prohibition was an infringement of freedom of the press and basic rights.
The complainants included the publisher of Cambridge University economics professor Chang Ha-joon’s “Bad Samaritans,” which was published in 2007 and has sold more than 550,000 copies so far. The ministry criticized it as “anti-capitalist.”
He noted that the measure was taken for soldiers, a very specific group of people, rather than the general public.
“The administration has the autonomy to protect the morale of service members with its own guidelines,” he said adding that the ban does not infringe on their rights.
In 2010, the Constitutional Court ruled the military authorities’ prohibition constitutional.
By Bae Ji-sook (baejisook@heraldcorp.com)
-
Articles by Korea Herald
